Finalist 2024

A Vehicle for Co-Design : Designing an Accessible Makervan with People with Intellectual Disabilities

Jacqueline Johnstone, Monash University Human-Centred Computing / Kirsten Ellis, Monash University Human-Centred Computing / Swamy Ananthanarayan, Monash University Human-Centred Computing / Troy Mcgee, Monash University / Wallara Australia

A hands-on design strategy to engage people with intellectual disabilities and their support community in the design of a makervan.

The Accessible Makervan employed a pioneering co-design strategy to engage people with intellectual disabilities and their support community in the design of a mobile makerspace. Leveraging the hands-on nature of bodystorming, speculative use scenarios for the mobile makerspace were developed, performed and evaluated by people with intellectual disabilities, their support coaches and Wallara’s leadership team. Developed in collaboration with Monash University and Wallara, the Makervan is equipped with standard makerspace equipment such as a 3D printer, electronic kits and a laser cutter made accessible via roll-out shelving and a wheelchair lift, for daily use across six of Wallara sites.

Design Brief:

The Makervan was created in collaboration with Wallara, a multisite disability support organisation that delivers a STEAM (Science, Technology, Engineering, Arts, and Math) program of support to their clients. Establishing a centralised makerspace for Wallara was deemed impractical, due to the number of sites, and the requirement for specialised equipment and staff knowledge. The challenge was to design a mobile makerspace for and with people with varied cognitive, motor and communication abilities, that could adapt to their diverse needs and the capabilities of local learning environments.

In response to this challenge, a co-design strategy was implemented, inclusively engaging people with intellectual disabilities in designing a makervan to facilitate accessible STEAM learning and exploration experiences.


This project was developed by:

Design Process

A three-phase approach to co-designing the Makervan was employed where people with intellectual disabilities, support coaches and Wallara’s leadership team participated in (1) preliminary interviews, (2) bodystorming and (3) reflective interviews. Through an iterative and collaborative process, an inclusive strategy for co-designing the Makervan with and for the community it sought to serve was developed and executed. The project engaged 32 stakeholders, including people with intellectual disabilities (clients), support workers (coaches) and Wallara’s leadership team. This engagement spanned over 100 hours, including ethnographic observations, preliminary interviews, bodystorming workshops, and reflective interviews. This process yielded insights that identified the need for a mobile makerspace, to adapt to the diverse capabilities of local learning environments while promoting inclusive participation and exposure to STEAM materials among clients.

We present the outcome of a co-designed mobile makervan, equipped with standard makerspace equipment such as electronics, robotics, programming, construction, modelling and eTextile materials. These resources were made safe and accessible through co-designed resource shelving and storage containers, and are used daily in the Makervan across six of Wallara’s sites. The Makervan provides a unique opportunity for people with intellectual disabilities to engage in making technologies themselves, an experience often limited by the physical, cognitive and social inaccessibilities of traditional makerspaces.

Design Excellence

The Makervan was co-designed with and for people with intellectual disabilities, to support their access to STEAM learning and exploration resources. The Makervan’s co-design strategy centred on the experiences of people with intellectual disabilities, leveraging their abilities and embodied communication channels to engage in the design decision-making process.

Verbal communication can be a barrier when working with individuals with intellectual disabilities, necessitating the exploration and implementation of alternative ‘hands-on’ modes of participation and communication. This led to a series of bodystorming workshops being carried out as both an engagement and co-design tool, enabling the sharing of clients’ perspectives through the provision of an embodied ’voice’ among non or minimally-verbal participants during co-design activities. Consequently facilitating the equitable performance, speculation and evaluation of the Makervan’s prospective functional and aesthetic design features among Wallara’s clients, coaches, and leadership. As recognised by one site coach, through enacting the scenarios in context with contextually relevant props, “the clients had the opportunity to talk about the layout of the van and what they wanted in it. I think that is really why it’s such a positive thing for clients”.

The Makervan is made accessible and safe through the informed selection of STEAM materials and the design of resource shelving and storage containers. It services six sites to offer enriching STEAM experiences to Wallara’s clients, which would not otherwise be financially or ecologically sustainable. The nature of a mobile makerspace ensures that the number of sites can grow into the future, and other initiatives, such as outreach events, can be supported.

Design Innovation

Electronic-making activities, like 3D printing and laser cutting, are generally not possible for people with intellectual disabilities. This is largely driven by community perceptions that regard such activities are unsafe, inappropriate or inaccessible. By co-designing the Makervan with and for the Wallara community, this project not only validated the feasibility and acceptability of the Makervan, but also dispelled misconceptions that could have hindered end-users’ engagement with electronic-making and STEAM experiences.

One client, with limited mobility and communication skills, demonstrated capabilities beyond the initial expectations set by coaches. When participating in a bodystorming scenario that involved the manipulation of the Makervan’s storage resources, the client garnered praise from a Wallara coach who expressed “I’m actually really happy and surprised that he knew how to do this”.

Another client superseded active participation to acquire a co-facilitator role during the bodystorming session. This client assumed responsibility for mapping out the dimensions of the Makervan onto the ground using tape and led the ideation process for designing storage and equipment features. Demonstrating her enthusiasm, the client asserted “you might as well get me to do the whole thing”. Their coach acknowledged the client’s engagement, stating “this is good because she enjoyed this, sitting in the van and then plotting a design, she just ran with it”.

This project underscores the potential for coaches, staff and researchers to recognise the practical knowledge and engage people with intellectual disabilities in design decision-making processes through a hands-on co-design strategy.

Design Impact

The Makervan demonstrates the capabilities of people living with intellectual disabilities and shifts mindsets about what meaningful STEAM participation looks like, including to the design-research team and Wallara’s staff alike. Since its deployment, the Makervan has provided hundreds of hours of hands-on STEAM engagement to people with intellectual disabilities. This impact continues to grow, as the Makervan supports Wallara in delivering inclusive STEAM participation opportunities to an increasing number of Melbourne sites. The coordinator of Wallara’s STEAM program emphasised the inclusive value of the Makervan’s weekly visits, highlighting that “seeing the van come every week, it’s so special for the Pakenham site, the connection of having somebody coming to them”. The Makervan provides access to STEAM education and enrichment activities for individuals with intellectual disabilities who’ve expressed their interest in engaging with the field of STEAM. When engaging with the Makervan, the accomplishments of clients’ often surpass coaches’ expectations. “You always see clients doing and making things that you never thought would come out” remarked one coach. This sentiment resonates with Wallara’s CEO, who “likes surprising people. Because it means they change to [recognise] ‘oh, I didn’t know that people with a disability could do that’”. The Makervan serves as an encouraging precedent, aiming to inspire the inclusion of individuals with intellectual disabilities in future co-design strategies and STEAM engagement opportunities. The impact of this work may be realised by informing practices for designing with people with intellectual disabilities and encouraging diversified participation in STEAM.

Student Design 2024 Finalists

IMITATION

RMIT School of Architecture and Urban Design: Interior Design / Xiaoni Bai / Linda Raimondo (Tutor)

PIVOT

Maya Schwalb

Beyond the Masterplan

Jessica Riazaty / Professor Mark Jacques

Sorbet

Sze Tjin Yek

Rigrowing City

Zhuoran ‘Amanda’ Chen / Zixin Wang / Dr Ding Wen ‘Nic’ Bao (Supervisor), RMIT University, School of Architecture and Urban Design

The BiliLumen Phototherapy Lamp

Shashank Rathor / Whistle Design Group

CryoCare: Reimagining Antibiotic Delivery in the Community

Geoffrey Thompson / Rowan Page / Ben Rogers / Monash Design Health Collab / Monash Health / ALPAKA Gear

The Citarum Current Collection

Monash University / Anja Johansen / Citarum Action Research Program (CARP)

Luis Perkins

Nurture: Building a Sensory Connection to Nature

Jordana Marks

Jordana Marks / Supervised by Joshua Riesel and Charlie Richardson

Otherworldly Expedition: The Sentient City

RMIT Architecture and Urban Design: Interior Design / Anh Tran / Dr. Andy Miller (Supervisor)

REVR

Alexander Burton

Ridgeline Tactile Pack

Makushla Harper / Supervisors: Dr Emma Luke & Dr Soumitri Varadarajan

BryMay Theatre

Sagar Talwai / Joshua Roberts / Dr Ding Wen ‘Nic’ Bao (Supervisor) / Geng ‘Greg’ Gong (Supervisor) , RMIT University, School of Architecture and Urban Design

Six Sticks

Kaspian Kan

RE:CML (2024)

RMIT Architecture and Urban Design: Interior Design / Xiaoni Bai / James Carey (Supervisor)

Wonki

Wonki / Shadowboxer